November 01, 2026

Proposing in New York Over the Holidays: When to Order the Ring

Written by Sue Kim, founder of Haejin Jewelry in Williamsburg, Brooklyn
Published November 2026

Nearly half of all engagements happen between November and February, according to The Knot's most recent Real Weddings Study, and Christmas Day is the single most popular day of the year to ask. Which means that right now, in the first week of November, a few thousand people are quietly planning the biggest question of their lives for a date six weeks out.

Almost none of them know that the ring has a deadline, and that it has already started counting down.

Every ring I sell is made by hand, one at a time, for one person. We design it together, usually across a table at my studio on Skillman Avenue in Williamsburg, and then it is built by hand to that drawing. That is a wonderful way to get a ring. It is also a slow way to get a ring, and slow does not care that your flight lands on the twenty-third.

So here is the thing nobody in my industry likes to publish: the actual dates. Not a vague "order early for the holidays." The real last day I can take a from-scratch ring and still put it in your hand before you ask.

Gold engagement ring held in a torch flame during hand soldering
Every ring here is soldered by hand, one at a time. That is what the three to four weeks are for.

The holiday ring deadlines, 2026

A ring made from scratch here takes three to four weeks to build once the design is settled and the deposit is in. The dates below work backward from that, and they include a few days of insured shipping and a small buffer, because December is not the month to find out your carrier was optimistic.

You want to ask on Last day to approve the design and place the deposit Rush still possible until
Thanksgiving
Thu Nov 26
Already passed for a ring built from nothing. Only if the stone is already in my hands. Write to me today, not tomorrow.
Christmas Eve or Christmas Day
Thu Dec 24, Fri Dec 25
Friday Nov 20 Friday Dec 4
New Year's Eve
Thu Dec 31
Tuesday Nov 24 Thursday Dec 10
Valentine's Day
Sun Feb 14, 2027
Friday Jan 15 Friday Jan 29

If you are flying in, move every date one week earlier. Choosing a stone by email takes longer than choosing one across a table. Figure on about a week of back and forth on stones and drawings before the clock in that table even starts. For a Christmas proposal, that means getting in touch by Friday Nov 13.

For comparison, most of the ateliers in this city stop somewhere in the same window. One Manhattan studio cuts off on November 20. Another adds two weeks to every order placed after November 6 and then closes entirely from December 19 to January 4. A well known Brooklyn jeweler will not accept a single rush request between October 25 and January 15, at all, for any reason.

I take rush work. Not always, and not infinitely, but I would rather tell you honestly whether it fits than send you away in November. One client last month had a proposal date set overseas and setbacks had eaten his schedule down to four weeks. He wrote about it afterward:

"I came to her with a custom design and not nearly enough time. I had a proposal date set overseas, and the schedule was tight from day one. Sue took the job anyway, was patient through every revision, and gave me honest advice on what would actually work. When things got down to the wire, she went out of her way to make sure I'd have a ring in my pocket no matter what. The ring got to me in time. She said yes, and she loves it."

"But please don't be me. Don't wait until the last minute." Aleksey, Google review, October 2026

Take his advice before you take mine.

If you have already missed the date

You have not missed the proposal. You have only missed one route to it. There are two others, and I have watched both of them end in a yes.

Ask with a stand-in. A simple band, a ring that belonged to someone in your family, even a loop of ribbon. You ask on Christmas morning with the thing you have, and then the two of you come in together in January and design the real one. Every year a handful of couples do this, and every one of them tells me afterward that designing it together became part of the story rather than a consolation for missing a deadline. If she has opinions about jewelry, and most people do, this is quietly the better plan anyway.

Move the date. Valentine's Day is seven weeks after New Year's and it is the third most popular day to propose in America. Nobody will ever know Christmas was Plan A.

Where people actually ask, in December

Brooklyn in late December does something to the light. The sun is gone by half past four, the sky over the East River goes the color of a bruised peach, and because everyone is indoors drinking, the waterfront belongs to whoever is willing to stand in the cold.

  • Brooklyn Bridge Park, Pebble Beach. Manhattan lit up across the water, the bridge over your shoulder. Go at sunset on a weekday, not a weekend.
  • Jane's Carousel in DUMBO. Glass pavilion, warm light, the carousel turning behind you. It photographs beautifully and it is indoors, which in December matters more than people expect.
  • Dyker Heights. The Christmas lights are genuinely absurd. Go on a weeknight in the second week of December, before the tour buses take over.
  • Brooklyn Heights Promenade. Short, narrow, and the single best view of lower Manhattan at night. Early evening, before the dog walkers.

That is the short list. I have written a much longer one, spot by spot, with permits, timing, photographers and what each place is actually like on the ground, in my full guide to Brooklyn and NYC proposal spots. If you are still deciding where, start there and come back here for the ring.

Flying in with a ring, or flying in to get one

Half the people who write to me in December are not from here. They are coming for the holidays, or coming because New York in December is itself the gesture. A few practical things I have learned from them.

Carry it on. Never put a ring in checked luggage. TSA has no problem with jewelry in a carry-on, and you do not have to declare it or announce it. If you are travelling with the person you intend to surprise, the ring box is the problem, not the ring. Bring the ring in a small soft pouch inside something boring, a sock, a contact lens case, a camera bag, and leave the box at home or buy one here.

Do not have it shipped to a hotel. Hotels lose things and front desks sign for packages on behalf of strangers. If you are travelling, either collect the ring from the studio in person or have it sent to your home before you leave. I ship insured, overnight or two day, signature required, and I would rather hand it to you.

Come in early in your trip, not late. If anything needs adjusting, and sometimes something does, I want days to fix it rather than hours. My studio is at 123 Skillman Ave STO in Williamsburg. I am open Tuesday, Thursday and Friday from 11 to 5, Saturday 11 to 6, and Sunday 11 to 4, and I am closed Mondays and Wednesdays. Build that into your week. If you are staying in Midtown it is about twenty five minutes on the L, and if you are staying in our neighborhood it is a walk.

Her ring size, without asking

The question I get most in December, usually in a slightly panicked email. Options, in order of how well they work.

Borrow a ring she already wears on that hand and bring it to me, or press it into a bar of soap and photograph the impression. Ask her sister, her mother or her closest friend, who very likely already knows and has been waiting years for someone to ask. Or accept that you will guess, and let me build the ring so it can be adjusted comfortably later. Guessing slightly large is kinder than guessing small. A ring that spins a little on Christmas morning is a two day fix in January. A ring that will not go past the knuckle is a photograph nobody wants.

What I would not do is use one of those printable paper sizers at two in the morning. They are wrong often enough that I have stopped recommending them.

Emerald cut three stone engagement ring with pear side stones in yellow gold, worn on the hand in warm light
An emerald cut with pear shoulders, in yellow gold. Made for one person, and only ever made once.

If you do not live here, and never will

This is the honest objection, and somebody raised it with me only a few weeks ago. She was in California, she loved what we had drawn together, and she chose a jeweler near her instead. Her reason was good: she wanted someone she could walk to for the next twenty years of resizing and prong checks and the day a stone works loose.

I am not going to pretend that a studio in Brooklyn is as convenient as a shop in your town. It is not. What I will tell you is how it actually works, because I have made rings for people in Texas, Florida, Colorado, South Carolina and Oregon, several of whom have never stood in my studio.

We talk on the phone. I send photographs of real stones, video of them turning in the light, and the lab reports. You see a rendering before anything is cast and nothing moves forward until you approve it. When it is finished it ships insured and signed for. Afterward, care is by mail: you send it to me, I do the work, I send it back. That is a slower loop than walking down your street, and for some people that trade is the wrong one. It is worth deciding which kind of person you are before you order, not after.

"I was nervous about ordering an engagement ring online, especially from a small business. It's not something you buy everyday and I wasn't sure if it would look the same in person." brian l., Yelp review, September 2025

He ordered it anyway, from out of state, and it did look the same in person. But his nervousness was reasonable, and I would rather acknowledge it than sell past it.

What you are actually buying, when you buy it from me

There is a version of this purchase where a ring is pulled from a drawer of two thousand identical rings, and there is nothing wrong with that version. It is faster and it is often cheaper.

This is the other version. I will know the stone in your ring by sight, because I chose it. I will have had the finished ring in my hands before it was boxed, and if the prongs were a hair off it went back. When you bring it back in nine years with a bent claw, I will remember the ring, because only one of them was ever made. One client wrote that the turnaround was under two weeks for a completely custom ring, which is true and which I am proud of, but speed is not really the point. The point is that somebody made it, on purpose, for one person.

If you want to see how a one of a kind ring comes together, that page walks through it properly.

Interior of the Haejin Jewelry studio in Williamsburg, Brooklyn, with display cases and the studio sign
The studio on Skillman Avenue. Come early in your trip, not the morning you fly home.

Questions I get in November and December

When do I need to order a ring for a Christmas proposal?

For a ring built from scratch, the design needs to be settled and the deposit placed by Friday November 20, 2026. A rush is possible until Friday December 4. If you live outside New York, add a week to both dates to allow for choosing stones by email, so reach out by Friday November 13.

Can I fly with an engagement ring?

Yes. Keep it in your carry-on, never in checked luggage. You do not need to declare it. If you are travelling with the person you plan to surprise, leave the ring box behind and carry the ring in a soft pouch tucked inside something unremarkable.

Can you deliver the ring to my hotel in New York?

I would rather not. Hotel front desks sign for packages on behalf of guests and things go missing at exactly the wrong moment. Collect it from the studio in person, or have it shipped to your home address before you travel.

How do I find out her ring size without asking?

Borrow a ring she wears on that hand, or press it into soap and send me a photograph of the impression. Asking her sister or closest friend works more often than people expect. If you have to guess, guess slightly large. A loose ring is an easy fix later, a tight one ruins the moment.

What if I miss the deadline entirely?

Propose with a stand-in ring and design the real one together in January, choose something already finished and have it sized in a few days, or move the question to Valentine's Day. All three happen every year and all three end the same way.

Who looks after the ring if I live in another state?

Care is handled by mail. You send the ring to me, I do the work, I send it back insured. It is slower than a jeweler on your own street, and that is a real trade worth weighing before you order rather than after.

One last thing

If you are reading this in the first half of November, you have time and you should stop reading and start deciding. If you are reading it in December, write to me anyway and tell me the date. I will tell you honestly whether it fits, and if it does not, I will tell you that too, which is worth something in a month when everybody else is just saying yes.

You can also think about whether to ask or to decide it together, or look at what couples here actually spend. And if what you are really after is a gift rather than a question, I wrote something separate about buying fine jewelry at Christmas without rushing a forever decision.

Tell me your date

Haejin Jewelry, 123 Skillman Ave STO, Brooklyn NY 11211